SC refuses to intervene on plea against making vaccine must | India News – Times of India

NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court on Monday refused to intervene on a plea that vaccinations should not be made mandatory, saying the steps were being taken by countries across the world to push vaccination and no measure should be taken that will fuel vaccine hesitancy.
While agreeing to hear a PIL seeking disclosure of clinical trial data of Covid vaccines, the SC said doubts should not be created about vaccine efficacy without scientific proof as many people are already reluctant to take the shots key to contain the pandemic.
A bench of Justices L Nageswara Rao and Aniruddha Bose issued notice to the Centre seeking response on a plea filed by former member of the National Technical Advisory Group on Immunisation, Jacob Puliyel, for making public segregated data from the clinical trials.
The bench refrained from passing any direction on other issues relating to vaccines, saying it may seed doubt in the minds of people.
Advocate Prahant Bhushan, appearing for the petitioner, said he did not seek any direction to stop the vaccination drive, but it should not be made mandatory. He said though the government on paper is taking the stand that it is voluntary, authorities have passed various vaccine mandated directions which make vaccination virtually mandatory.
The bench, however, said such practices were being adopted by various countries across the world to push vaccination and the court should not interfere at this stage. “Worldwide it is being done. We are facing a situation which we did not face in the last hundred years. As per World Health Organisation, vaccine hesitancy is one of the major problems facing the world. Would it not amount to throwing doubts in the mind of people if we pass any order,” the bench said.
Bhushan claimed vaccine hesitancy was among highly educated people with scientific knowledge and doubt about the efficacy of vaccines cannot be brushed aside and should be evaluated scientifically for which data was needed He also claimed there had been adverse impact of vaccines and more than 12,000 people died in the US.
“In India, the manner in which vaccines have been licensed vitiates and even precludes the possibility that the vaccines can be evaluated objectively in the future. Under these circumstances the petitioner is forced to appeal to this court for public disclosure of trial data and post-vaccination data, as required by international medical norms,” the petition said.
Justice Rao, however, said he came to know that many doctors were saying that they were not aware on how the body would react to vaccines but said the court should not pass any order which creates more confusion as the situation is “very dangerous”.
“Nobody will be safe if everybody is not vaccinated and that is something that is being done across the world,” the bench said while supporting government decision to push people to get vaccinated.

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Open chat